Lab grown or natural diamonds: an honest comparison

Lab grown or natural diamonds: an honest comparison

This is the question we are asked most often in the boutique, and the honest answer is that it depends on what you value. Here is what actually separates the two, without the marketing from either side.

They are the same material

A lab grown diamond is a diamond. It has the same carbon structure, the same hardness of ten on the Mohs scale, the same refractive index and the same sparkle. It is not a simulant. Cubic zirconia and moissanite are simulants, and they look different to a trained eye. A lab grown diamond does not, because it is not imitating anything.

How each one is made

Natural diamonds formed one to three billion years ago, roughly 150 kilometres below the surface, and were carried up by volcanic activity. Lab grown diamonds are made in a few weeks, either by high pressure high temperature, which mimics those conditions, or by chemical vapour deposition, which builds the crystal layer by layer from carbon gas.

A laboratory can tell the difference, using equipment that reads growth patterns and trace elements. You cannot, and neither can a jeweller with a loupe.

The price difference is the real story

Lab grown diamonds typically cost substantially less per carat than a natural stone of equivalent grading. For most people the practical consequence is simple: the same budget buys a noticeably larger or better graded stone.

That difference has widened as lab production has scaled. It is worth knowing that this cuts both ways. Natural diamonds have held value reasonably well over long periods, while lab grown prices have fallen year on year. If you are thinking about resale, that matters. If you are buying something to wear rather than to trade, it matters much less than people assume, because retail jewellery of any kind rarely resells well.

What about ethics and environment

Both categories can be responsibly or irresponsibly sourced, and blanket claims from either side deserve scepticism. Lab growing uses significant energy, and how clean that energy is varies enormously by producer. Mining has a physical footprint, but in several countries it is also a major employer and a source of public revenue.

If this is your deciding factor, ask for specifics rather than slogans: which laboratory, which mine, what certification.

Certification applies to both

Any stone worth buying comes with a report from GIA, IGI or HRD Antwerp, and that report states clearly whether the diamond is natural or laboratory grown. If a seller is vague about this, walk away. In many countries, including across the EU, describing a lab grown stone without qualifying it is a legal problem, not just a moral one.

So which should you choose

Choose natural if the origin story matters to you, or if you want the stone to hold its value as well as such things can.

Choose lab grown if you would rather put the budget into size, cut quality or the setting.

There is no wrong answer here, and anyone who tells you otherwise is usually selling one of the two.

We sell both, and we will show you the same stone in each so you can compare them side by side in the boutique.

Back to blog
Still deciding?

Talk it through with us

Book a private appointment opposite Antwerp Central Station, or ask us on a video call.

Book an appointment